After years of analysis and introspection, I've finally found out what is wrong with me. I didn't have a Chinese mother.
Thanks to the article from the Wall Street Journal
It must be that having an American white Anglo Saxon Protestant mother was the cause of all my issues.
According to Ms Chua, a Professor of Law at Yale,
here's the Chinese way of superior mothering:
A lot of people wonder how Chinese parents raise such stereotypically successful kids. They wonder what these parents do to produce so many math whizzes and music prodigies, what it's like inside the family, and whether they could do it too. Well, I can tell them, because I've done it. Here are some things my daughters, Sophia and Louisa, were never allowed to do:
• attend a sleepover• have a playdate
• be in a school play
• complain about not being in a school play
• watch TV or play computer games
• choose their own extracurricular activities
• get any grade less than an A
• not be the No. 1 student in every subject except gym and drama
• play any instrument other than the piano or violin
• not play the piano or violin.
But be sure to read the entire article to understand her more about her mothering methods.
Just imagine the accomplishments that I could have had in my youth and the success in my adult life if my mother had just raised me the Chinese way!
Let's see, obviously I was raised with vast disadvantages.
To name a few I was a girl scout, I went to camp, I slept over at my friend's houses, I watched tv, I practiced the piano less than 2 hours a day, I was in a school play, I was in honors classes but I wasn't required to be the best in every subject....sadly, I could go on and on.
It's true that in my early childhood, my mother was not only busy raising 3 children, she was also involved in her ladies group, where no doubt there were fashion shows and gourmet cooking parties. She was sporty too and played a lot of tennis at the country club. Later in my childhood, she worked and I was a latch key kid.
Obviously, she didn't micro manage my life nor my brother's lives.
Don't get me wrong, I would have preferred to have had a more involved mother and Mrs. Chua is certainly correct about the benefits of studying music and about setting high goals for your children.
Economist Thomas Sowell from the Hoover Institute has written about how certain ethnic groups are more likely to succeed because of their emphasis on education.
Indeed, many American parents are only too happy to abandon all standards for their children and over indulge them with toys, computer games and tv, and under indulge them with academic expectations.
Sill, I wonder, does Rupert Murdoch's Chinese wife, Wendy Deng Murdoch, spend every afternoon monitoring her two daughter's homework and piano lessons.
Also, given that China had the culture that practiced foot binding and brought us Jiang Qing, aka Madame Mao, another fine example of a Chinese mother, why did the Journal choose to publish this article?


8 comments:
Hi Belle
I've just found your blog through Faux Fuchsia!
I have been itching to write something about this article.
Where do I start? What was its actual purpose? To gloat and be smug? To promote already painful and negative racial stereotypes?
I'm Chinese myself and though I can identify with some of the 'criteria' so 'tactfully' listed, I feel that what is missing is the fact that the reason many Chinese mothers 'push' their children is out of love and a desire for a better life than what they have. Many older Chinese women are very stoic and would never 'lose face' and tell their kids how hard their lives may have been in the past. Much better to push onward and upward.
It may be misguided but its intentions are often more noble and borne of love than what the results may suggest.
All parents want what is best for their children. Perhaps the focus of the article should have been finding a happy medium between the pressure of Asian parenting and the more supportive Western focus.
Totally agree, I did wonder about Wendy Deng.... Perhaps she finds time in between Hello and Vogue shoots and running businesses. Via a web cam?
Take care and sorry for the long rant...
SSG xxx
PS - what kind of law professor needs to publicly link herself to this kind of writing in the WSJ?
Sydney Shop Girl blog
Hmmm. I'm glad I didn't have a Chinese mother! Hope all's well with you xx
Sydney Shop Girl welcome and thank you for your comment.
I was just really shocked by this article and fact that the WSJ chose to publish it. I don't know if you noticed or not that the WSJ had over 1400 comments about it and the vast majority of them were negative.
I have nothing against having high academic and other expectations for children. I might add that well over $200,000 in private school fees and other educational fees has gone into educating EACH of my two children, and neither of them have been to graduate school... yet.
So do I have high expectations for them based on the financial investment and the time that I invested in raising them? You bet.
I believe that children have to develop some level of empathy and socialization skills which scouting, team sports and group events can develop.
I also believe in letting children fail to some degree in certain areas. Children, and others often learn more from the experience of failure than from continued success.
And, I do believe that we have become much to loosey-goosey with raising our children. But I don't see this as an Asian vs Western thing or more specifically Chinese vs American.
Also, living in Los Angeles where we have a vast Asian community of Chinese, Japanese, and Korean Americans, the private school system is very competitive. We also have Russians, Israelis and other immigrant families who raise the academic bar for all students.
I could go on an on about this article, I just didn't like the smug racist tone of writer.
Mmmm I might have found myself out on the streets! I'm sure the issue here isn't the creed/culture or race more the escape from the past striving towards something that was lost as Sydney Shop Girl says.
I'm a dreadfully strict mother but I'm not in the position to do all the things as qualified in the article because the foundation of wealth is the underpinning of this. Petit garcon has to sit in front of the tv at times as I have household chores to do!
I do hate judgemental articles and many an overachieving child have crumbled in adulthood. You need to have fun and frolics too.
xx
Christina, yes...somehow my brothers and I have muddled through life without being raised by a Chinese mother. Of course, none of us are doctors, lawyers, classical musicians or indian chiefs.
MDS, yes very well said.
Hi! I found the article very interesting. First I got it wrong and read the kids were super BECAUSE they went to sleepovers and participated in school plays, because that's what I did as a kid! ... and I turned out super ;-))
Right now there are already over 2000 comments, also from Chinese mothers (raised in China, living in the US) who call the way she treats her kids abusive. I would say any parent who yells so much at his kid that he or she loses his/her voice is abusing the child. Verbal cruelty can be very hurting. The Chinese people I met in the West so far were all very, very kind, warm personalities. I wonder of the drill in China can be commpared to the drill in Japan? We watched children walking home from school in Japan AFTER we left the dinner-place. We were shocked!
Reading the article reminded me of my childhood but now i think i would have the same of my potential kids b/c it really helped me with my foundation. I didn't appreciate it back then but boy do I appreciate it now.
I found it difficult to read beyond the list of "not alloweds" at the beginning of the article. My daughter is prepping her room for her first sleepover tomorrow night; I cannot imagine denying her that experience!
Post a Comment